Over 90% of all ISO Management System certifications are for ISO 9001, leaving less than 10% to cover the other 50+ ISO Management System Standards.
When organizations seek to enhance their management systems, they often get confused about whether to implement ISO 9001 for a broad quality management foundation or to dive directly into a specialized standard that addresses a specific area of their operations. This uncertainty often arises from a lack of clarity regarding each standard's distinct focus and benefits. The decision can be challenging because it depends on the organization's needs, customer expectations, industry requirements, and long-term goals.
In this article, we'll compare ISO 9001 with other frequently implemented ISO standards to help you determine if ISO 9001 alone meets your needs or if a more specific standard is necessary to achieve your organizational objectives.
Many modern ISO standards, including ISO 9001 (Quality Management System), ISO 45001 (Occupational Health and Safety Management System), ISO 14001 (Environmental Management System), and others, share a common high-level structure known as Annex SL. This standardizes the core structure across management system standards, making integration and comparison easier. For example, terms, definitions, and core requirements follow a similar format, aiding organizations in implementing multiple standards simultaneously.
Note: In May 2021, ISO published the revised Annex SL. With this, the HLS underwent a revision with various clarifications, additions, and deletions. The term High-Level Structure has been dropped and is now called the "Harmonized Structure" (HS, and the term "Harmonized Approach" (HA" is also used.
ISO 9001 prioritizes customer focus, strong leadership, engaged employees, efficient processes, continuous improvement, data-driven decisions, and positive relationships. These principles are foundational and echoed in other ISO standards, making ISO 9001 a benchmark for understanding and comparing the principles behind various management systems.
ISO 9001 is one of the most widely adopted standards globally. It applies to any organization regardless of size, industry, or type. More than 90% of all ISO Certifications are for ISO 9001. Its widespread use provides a common reference point for organizations seeking to implement or compare other ISO standards specific to their industry or operational needs.
Organizations often pursue certification for multiple ISO standards to cover different aspects of their operations (e.g., quality, environmental impact, occupational health, and safety). ISO 9001 serves as a base for integrating these standards, allowing organizations to build an integrated management system that efficiently meets multiple requirements.
The emphasis on continual improvement in ISO 9001 aligns with similar requirements in other ISO standards. This commonality fosters comparisons as organizations look to streamline processes, reduce redundancies, and enhance overall performance across different management domains.
ISO 9001 introduces a risk-based approach to management systems, a concept echoed in standards like ISO 45001 and ISO 14001. This focus on risk management and mitigation is critical to modern management systems, making ISO 9001 a helpful reference point.
ISO 9001 has existed for several decades, influencing the development of newer standards. As organizations and industries evolved, the learnings and frameworks from ISO 9001 helped shape other standards, making natural and necessary comparisons.
Similarities |
Differences |
||
|---|---|---|---|
ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 |
ISO 9001 |
ISO 13485 |
|
| High-Level Structure (Annex SL): Both ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 follow the Annex SL framework, which standardizes management system standard structure and core requirements. This common structure includes sections on the organization's context, leadership, planning, support, operation, performance evaluation, and improvement. | ISO 9001 focuses on general quality management principles applicable to any organization, regardless of its products or services. It emphasizes meeting customer requirements and enhancing customer satisfaction. | ISO 13485 focuses specifically on quality management systems for medical devices. It includes additional requirements related to regulatory compliance, risk management, design and development, and traceability specific to the medical device industry. | |
| Process Approach: Both standards emphasize a process-based approach to management. They require organizations to identify, define, and manage their key processes to achieve their objectives efficiently and consistently. | ISO 9001 requires organizations to identify laws and regulations relevant to their products and services (which may include general regulatory requirements) and comply with them. | ISO 13485 emphasizes regulatory compliance specific to the medical device industry. It requires organizations to comply with the laws and regulations of the areas where they operate, such as FDA regulations in the United States and CE marking requirements in the European Union. | |
| Continual Improvement: ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 both emphasize the importance of continual improvement. Organizations must systematically monitor and evaluate their processes, products, and quality management systems and implement measures to enhance them over time. | ISO 9001 addresses product realization processes in a general context, focusing on ensuring that products and services meet customer requirements and conform to specified standards. | ISO 13485 includes additional requirements tailored to the needs of the medical device industry, including design and development controls, validation of processes, and control of sterile products. | |
| Risk-Based Thinking: Both standards integrate risk-based thinking into their requirements. Organizations are expected to recognize and assess risks and opportunities related to their products and business operations and take appropriate actions to mitigate or exploit them. | ISO 9001 highlights the significance of meeting customer requirements and improving customer satisfaction. This standard applies to any organization. | ISO 13485 considers customer requirements within the context of medical devices, including requirements related to safety, effectiveness, and regulatory compliance specific to the medical device industry. | |
| Leadership Commitment: Both standards emphasize the importance of leadership commitment to the management system. Management must demonstrate leadership and commitment by actively participating in its establishment, implementation, and continual improvement. | ISO 9001 addresses product safety and performance as part of its focus on meeting customer requirements and enhancing customer satisfaction. | ISO 13485 places greater emphasis on product safety and performance specific to the medical device industry, including requirements related to risk management, clinical evaluation, and post-market surveillance. | |
Similarities |
Differences |
||
|---|---|---|---|
ISO 9001 and ISO 45001 |
ISO 9001 |
ISO 45001 |
|
|
High-Level Structure (Annex SL): Both ISO 9001 and ISO 45001 follow the Annex SL framework, which standardizes management system standards' structure and core requirements. This common structure includes sections on the organization's context, leadership, planning, support, operation, performance evaluation, and improvement. |
ISO 9001 focuses on general quality management principles applicable to any organization, regardless of its products or services. It emphasizes meeting customer requirements and enhancing customer satisfaction. | ISO 45001 focuses specifically on occupational health and safety management systems. It includes requirements for identifying hazards, assessing risks, implementing controls, and promoting a safe and healthy work environment. | |
|
Process Approach: Both standards emphasize a process-based approach to management. They require organizations to identify, define, and manage their key processes to achieve their objectives efficiently and consistently. |
ISO 9001 does not explicitly address occupational health and safety management. While it may include some requirements related to health and safety as part of its focus on meeting customer requirements and ensuring product and service conformity, it does not provide comprehensive guidance on occupational health and safety management. | ISO 45001 provides detailed requirements for establishing, implementing, and maintaining an occupational health and safety management system. It includes specific provisions for hazard identification, risk assessment, legal compliance, employee participation, and emergency preparedness and response. | |
|
Continual Improvement: ISO 9001 and ISO 45001 both emphasize the importance of continual improvement. Organizations must systematically monitor and evaluate their processes, products, and management systems and implement measures to enhance them over time. |
ISO 9001 mandates compliance with relevant laws and regulations for an organization's products and services. | ISO 45001 prioritizes workplace safety by requiring organizations to follow all relevant occupational health and safety laws and regulations. | |
|
Risk-Based Thinking: Both ISO 9001 and ISO 45001 emphasize risk-based thinking. Organizations must identify and assess risks and opportunities within their specific context and processes. This allows them to take appropriate actions to either minimize risks or capitalize on opportunities. |
ISO 9001 includes requirements related to employee competence, awareness, and communication. However, it does not explicitly address employee participation in the management system. | ISO 45001 emphasizes
employee involvement and consultation . Organizations must establish processes for involving workers in health and safety decision-making, hazard identification, and risk control. |
|
|
Leadership Commitment: Both standards emphasize the importance of leadership commitment to the management system. Top management must actively participate in setting up, implementing, and continually enhancing the system. |
ISO 9001 includes requirements related to emergency planning, such as identifying potential emergency situations and establishing response procedures. | ISO 45001 includes more detailed emergency preparedness and response requirements, including developing and implementing emergency plans, drills, and procedures to mitigate the consequences of potential emergencies. | |
|
Employee Involvement: Both standards recognize the importance of employee involvement and competence in achieving organizational objectives. They encourage organizations to engage employees at all levels, provide appropriate training, and create opportunities for involvement in decision-making processes. |
|||
Similarities |
Differences |
||
|---|---|---|---|
ISO 9001 and ISO 17025 |
ISO 9001 |
ISO 17025 |
|
|
High-Level Structure (Annex SL): Both ISO 9001 and ISO 17025 follow the Annex SL framework, which standardizes the structure and core requirements of management system standards. This common structure includes sections on the organization's context, leadership, planning, support, operation, performance evaluation, and improvement. |
ISO 9001 focuses on general quality management principles applicable to any organization, regardless of its products or services. It emphasizes meeting customer requirements and enhancing customer satisfaction. | ISO 17025 focuses specifically on testing and calibration laboratories. It includes requirements related to technical competence, quality control, proficiency testing, and | |
|
Process Approach: Both standards emphasize a process-based approach to management. They require organizations to identify, define, and manage their key processes to achieve their objectives efficiently and consistently. |
ISO 9001 addresses product and service conformity in a general context. It focuses on ensuring that products and services satisfy customers and follow established industry standards, promoting overall quality and competitiveness. | ISO 17025 emphasizes the technical aspects of product and service conformity, including the competence of personnel, the validity of test methods, the accuracy of measurements, and the traceability of results to national or international standards. | |
|
Customer focus: Both standards prioritize meeting customer requirements and enhancing customer satisfaction. They both emphasize understanding customer needs and expectations and aligning processes to meet them. |
ISO 9001 does not provide detailed technical requirements for specific industries or processes. Instead, it focuses on general quality management principles and requirements that can be applied to any organization. | ISO 17025 includes specific technical requirements tailored to testing and calibration laboratories, such as requirements for equipment calibration, measurement uncertainty estimation, sample handling, and test result reporting. | |
|
Documentation: Both standards require documentation of procedures, processes, and quality records. This ensures consistency, traceability, and the ability to demonstrate conformity to requirements. |
Under ISO 9001, organizations must systematically identify and comply with all applicable legal and regulatory requirements about their product and service offerings. | ISO 17025 emphasizes compliance with technical standards and regulations specific to testing and calibration laboratories, including accreditation and proficiency testing requirements. | |
|
Document Control: Both standards highlight the need to ensure that documents (such as procedures, work instructions, and records) are current, accurate, and readily available when needed. This helps maintain consistency, traceability, and compliance with requirements. |
ISO 9001 provides a framework for any organization to achieve excellence in customer satisfaction regardless of the nature of its business. | ISO 17025 considers customer requirements within the context of testing and calibration services, including requirements related to test methods, reporting formats, turnaround times, and confidentiality. | |
|
Continual Improvement: Both standards emphasize continual improvement. They push organizations or laboratories to constantly check their work, find ways to improve, and make the necessary changes to become more efficient and effective and deliver higher quality. |
|||
|
Training and Competence: Both standards ensure everyone has the skills and knowledge to do their jobs well. This includes providing appropriate training, education, and experience and establishing mechanisms to assess and maintain personnel competence. |
|||
Similarities |
Differences |
||
|---|---|---|---|
ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 |
ISO 9001 |
ISO 14001 |
|
|
High-Level Structure (Annex SL): Both ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 follow the Annex SL framework, which standardizes elements of management system standards. This common structure of management system standards includes sections on the organization's context, leadership, planning, support, operation, performance evaluation, and improvement. |
ISO 9001 focuses on quality management, addressing requirements related to ensuring products and services meet customer requirements and enhancing customer satisfaction. | ISO 14001 focuses on environmental management, addressing requirements for identifying and controlling an organization's environmental impact, preventing pollution, and improving environmental performance. | |
|
Process Approach: Both standards emphasize a process-based approach to management. They require organizations to identify, define, and manage their key processes to achieve their objectives efficiently and consistently. |
ISO 9001 helps businesses consistently deliver products and services that meet customer expectations and follow all regulations. | ISO 14001 aims to enhance environmental performance by controlling and minimizing an organization's environmental impact, including compliance with environmental laws. | |
|
Continual Improvement: Both ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 emphasize the importance of continual improvement. Organizations must systematically monitor and evaluate their processes, products, and management systems and implement measures to enhance them over time. |
ISO 9001 requires businesses to ensure the quality of products and services through continual improvement efforts. | ISO 14001 prioritizes environmental sustainability and requires organizations to improve their environmental performance consistently. | |
|
Risk-Based Thinking: Both ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 emphasize risk-based thinking, requiring organizations to identify and assess risks and opportunities within their specific context and processes. |
ISO 9001 includes requirements related to customer satisfaction and product conformity. | ISO 14001 emphasizes identifying and mitigating environmental risks associated with an organization's activities. | |
|
Employee Involvement: Both standards recognize the importance of employee involvement and competence in achieving organizational objectives. They encourage organizations to engage employees at all levels and create opportunities for involvement in decision-making processes. |
|||
Our closing advice is to think carefully before deciding that ISO 9001 is the 'right' choice. If it's not what your customers and future customers expect, you will have wasted time and opportunity. So, consider the pros and cons and talk to your customers first.
In October 2021, we secured certification to three education-related ISO Standards. Our university-grade management system conforms to the requirements of ……
We have chosen ISO 21001 certification because it is based on independent third-party assessment, unlike IRCA and Exemplar badges (which we believe are commercially compromised). It is a 'university grade' standard used globally by schools, colleges, and universities to demonstrate competence.
We provide Courses for ISO 9001, ISO 13485, ISO 14001, ISO 17025, ISO 27001, ISO 45001, Risk Management, Data Protection, and more.